With a provision of 22 November 2018, the Court of Auditors – Jurisdictional Section for the Puglia Region, in the context of the complaint, accepted the defensive theses of the managers of the Public Works service of the Municipality of Foggia.
The story arose following the eviction of the former Military District of Foggia. The Public Prosecutor at the Foggia Court accused the three managers of having favored the occupants by “deceiving” the financial service by determining payment for utilities not containing the details of the supply.
A totally free charge, as established by the Court of Review of Foggia with an order dated December 20, 2016, subsequently confirmed by the Court of Cassation.
On the basis of the same accusation, the Public Prosecutor of the Court of Auditors requested and obtained, on May 22, 2018, a decree of sequestration against the three managers, confirmed by the subsequent monochromatic ordinance of June 21, 2018 (filed on October 16, 2018).
Following the complaint proposed by the lawyers Michele Vaira and Francesco Paolo Bello, the Court of Auditors, in a collegiate composition, fully accepted the defensive thesis, amply supported by documentary evidence, according to which the three managers limited themselves to carrying out the will Ente.
The motivation reads: “from the documentation in documents from the first degree, and here proposed by the complainants, we can see the dating knowledge, by the municipality of Foggia, of the situation of continuing acceptance of the costs of the utilities of the families occupying the former barracks, in such a way as not to seem to exist, at least in the context of brief deliberation, that malicious concealment of the damage ».
The Court adopts some defense considerations:
a) the aforementioned seized, as illo tempore managers of the ll.pp. of the municipality of Foggia, seems to have done nothing but give continuity to a political will clearly and already ab originally intended to bear such charges, as highlighted by the same Court of the Review of Foggia, just order of 20.12.2016 (see, in particular , page 5), which, in the appeal de libertate, in the context of the proc. pen. n. 3198/15, from which this procedure took over, also excluded the willful misconduct of the crime of fraud (a crime, then, even more formulated when closing preliminary investigations);
b) some liquidation determinations, as early as 2004, contrary to what was claimed by the Prosecutor and considered by the first judge, clearly indicate the nature and purpose of the liquidation (see, for example, the executive decisions nos. 107 and 1566 of 2004 and the certificates of financial coverage of Resolution No. 298/07: Doc. 5-7 of the production of complainants);
c) the resolution of the Civil Code n. 195/2005, for the approval of the housing plan, contains, in its annexes, an indication of the situation of the illegal occupants of the former barracks, with charges borne by the municipal budget.
The Lawyer. Michele Vaira said: «After the initial amazement at the start of the procedure despite a very clear positive preliminary judgment in criminal proceedings, and the frustration suffered by the first order, which had bypassed what I believed (and which the Court believes today) unsurpassed arguments and defensive allegations, today’s provision restores justice and serenity) to my clients and prestige to the jurisdiction of the Court of Auditors.
This is a procedure in which, unfortunately, the defensive guarantees are reduced to the bone, and the rule of judgment, as interpreted by the Court’s jurisprudence, extremely unfavorable for those who are subjected to it.
It is important to reflect on the damage that these proceedings cause on the good performance of the Public Administration. Today an executive, for fear of having to answer in many years of tax damage, thinks about it a thousand times before putting a signature.
When, then, in cases like these, the public prosecutor’s office attributes the fraudulent component completely free of charge, one must defend oneself against acts committed ten years earlier, with enormous difficulty in articulating one’s defenses ».







