Vaira

FOGGIA

ROME

MILAN

INFO@STUDIOLEGALEVAIRA.IT
TEL. +39 0881 707 880

Law

INFO@STUDIOLEGALEVAIRA.IT
TEL. +39 0881 707 880

Close menu

Foggia football stewards: precautionary measure request rejected

03-05-2026 09:37

By order filed on 27 April 2026, the preliminary investigations judge (GIP) of the Court of Foggia, Dr Mario De Simone, rejected the prosecution’s request for a precautionary measure against Mr Donato Iuliani, represented by Studio Legale Vaira.

The decision is significant not only for its procedural outcome, but above all for the scope of the legal principles on which the judge based it. These principles fully converge with the defence arguments developed during months of investigation and culminating in the brief filed at the preventive interrogation.

The defence method: documentary reconstruction

The defence strategy was based on a rigorous and analytical approach: reconstructing, document by document, the real dynamics of the contractual and commercial relations under challenge, setting against the prosecution’s hypothesis a body of evidence made up of certified e-mails, contracts, invoices, bank transfers, message exchanges and civil court decisions.

It was thus possible to show that the Public Prosecutor’s case did not withstand comparison with the documents: the chronology of events, the subsequent conduct of the contracting parties and the independent initiative of the client company were radically incompatible with the legal framework of the main charge.

The precautionary battle was fought on this – strictly documentary – ground, and on this ground the judge recognised that the defence arguments were well founded.

The GIP’s decision

The judge held that the most serious offence charged was “not configurable”, relying precisely on the material produced by the defence and observing that the negotiating dynamics reconstructed were “highly unlikely” to fit the legal scheme put forward by the prosecution.

With regard to the other charges as well, the judge found that there was no serious evidence of guilt, accepting the defence arguments on the absence of the constituent elements of the offences charged.

The order consequently ends with the full rejection of the request for a precautionary measure and the return of the file to the Public Prosecutor.

The principle of law: the boundary between contractual dispute and criminal offence

The rejection of the precautionary measure represents the recognition that criminal law cannot be bent to treat as a crime what civil law, with its own tools, qualifies as a dispute within a contractual relationship. This is a statement of method that brings the case back to its correct legal dimension, restoring criminal proceedings to their status as extrema ratio.

Statement by Michele Vaira, attorney

“The order filed by the Preliminary Investigations Judge represents, even before a result for the defence, the affirmation of a method. Without the preventive interrogation introduced by the legislature – a mechanism that allowed the defence to bring the adversarial debate forward and to put the judge in a position to assess, alongside the prosecution’s file, the documents and arguments of the private party – the defendants would in all likelihood have been arrested. Anyone who practises criminal law knows this, and today it becomes concretely evident: preventive interrogation is a tool of procedural civility that protects personal liberty from restrictive measures based on an incomplete picture of the facts.

Credit must also be given to the legal refinement of Dr Mario De Simone. The judge interpreted the alleged conduct rigorously, distinguishing with surgical precision what belongs to a dispute within a contractual relationship from what amounts to typical criminal offences, and by legally qualifying the facts he restored them to their true weight. The result is a very clear picture that accounts for the complexity of the case without giving in to simplification.”

The defence expresses full satisfaction with the order, which protects Mr Iuliani’s personal liberty pending further developments in the proceedings, which will be approached with the same calm and the same technical rigour.

Gazzetta del Mezzogiorno, 29 April 2026

l’Attacco, 30 April 2026

Repubblica, 28 April 2026

Studio Legale Vaira

STUDIO LEGALE VAIRA